Anonymity, Signaling, and Silence as Speech

Anonymity, Signaling, and Silence as Speech
Author : Paul Horwitz
Publisher :
Total Pages : 20
Release : 2009
ISBN 10 : OCLC:1290256409
ISBN 13 :
Language : EN, FR, DE, ES & NL


This short article responds to a paper delivered by Professor Martin Redish at a symposium on Speech and Silence in American Law at the University of Alabama School of Law; the symposium proceedings will be published by Cambridge University Press. Professor Redish's paper argues for the elimination of First Amendment protection for expressive anonymity in certain cases involving political fraud.This response offers both clarifications and criticisms of Professor Redish's argument. It argues by way of clarification that the general category of quot;anonymityquot; is too broad to support useful analysis. Rather, we must consider the implications for Professor Redish's argument of at least two categories of speech: anonymous and pseudonymous speech. I show that even if we accept Professor Redish's account of the dangers of anonymous politically fraudulent speech, our concerns and prescriptions will vary greatly depending on what sort of quot;anonymousquot; speech we are talking about. Drawing on signaling theory, this response also offers a more critical treatment of Professor Redish's argument for the prohibition of some forms of anonymous speech. Signaling theory suggests that anonymous speech is not accurately characterized as part of the right of silence; instead, as an attributional decision that sends important signals about the reliability of the speech and the speaker, the choice of anonymity in fact constitutes a highly expressive form of speech. The signaling function of these attribution choices also suggests that Professor Redish's concerns about the misleading nature of anonymous politically fraudulent speech, and his recommendation that we curtail protection for this form of speech, are overstated.The signaling-based account of anonymity as speech has two subsidiary implications. First, contrary to Professor Redish's suggestion, it is impossible to disaggregate the rights of expressive and associational anonymity. Second, this account supports the argument of many writers that the Supreme Court ought to strongly reconsider its tangled jurisprudence concerning the permissibility of mandatory disclosure rules in the campaign finance laws, which is in tension with what the Court has written about anonymous speech in other contexts.

More Books:

Anonymity, Signaling, and Silence as Speech
Language: en
Pages: 20
Authors: Paul Horwitz
Categories:
Type: BOOK - Published: 2009 - Publisher:

This short article responds to a paper delivered by Professor Martin Redish at a symposium on Speech and Silence in American Law at the University of Alabama Sc
Speech and Silence in American Law
Language: en
Pages:
Authors: Austin Sarat
Categories: Law
Type: BOOK - Published: 2010-03-31 - Publisher: Cambridge University Press

Rather than abstract philosophical discussion or yet another analysis of legal doctrine, Speech and Silence in American Law seeks to situate speech and silence,
The Anonymous Signal
Language: en
Pages: 411
Authors: Erec Stebbins
Categories: Fiction
Type: BOOK - Published: 2015-07-04 - Publisher: Twice Pi Press

"STEBBINS IS THE MASTER OF THE THINKING READER'S TECHNO THRILLER" -Internet Review of Books No Forgiveness. No Forgetting. Expect It. The global financial syste
Security and Privacy in Communication Networks
Language: en
Pages: 369
Authors: Angelos D. Keromytis
Categories: Computers
Type: BOOK - Published: 2013-02-13 - Publisher: Springer

This volume presents the refereed proceedings of the 8th International ICST Conference on Security and Privacy in Communication Networks, SecureComm 2012, held
Information Security
Language: en
Pages: 446
Authors: Mike Burmester
Categories: Computers
Type: BOOK - Published: 2011-01-18 - Publisher: Springer

This book constitutes the refereed proceedings of the 13th International Conference on Information Security, ISC 2010, held in Boca Raton, FL, USA, in October 2
Signal Processing for Intelligent Sensor Systems with MATLAB®, Second Edition
Language: en
Pages: 683
Authors: David C. Swanson
Categories: Technology & Engineering
Type: BOOK - Published: 2011-07-21 - Publisher: CRC Press

Signal Processing for Intelligent Sensors with MATLAB®, Second Edition once again presents the key topics and salient information required for sensor design an
Signal Processing for Intelligent Sensor Systems with MATLAB, Second Edition
Language: en
Pages: 616
Authors: David C. Swanson
Categories: Technology & Engineering
Type: BOOK - Published: 2012 - Publisher: CRC Press

Building on the unique features that made the first edition a bestseller, this second edition includes additional solved problems and web access to the large co
Regulating Free Speech in a Digital Age
Language: en
Pages:
Authors: David Bromell
Categories:
Type: BOOK - Published: - Publisher: Springer Nature

Political Silence
Language: en
Pages: 198
Authors: Sophia Dingli
Categories: Political Science
Type: BOOK - Published: 2018-11-12 - Publisher: Routledge

The notion of ‘silence’ in Politics and International Relations has come to imply the absence of voice in political life and, as such, tends to be scholasti
The Deeper Dimension of Yoga
Language: en
Pages: 432
Authors: Georg Feuerstein, Ph.D.
Categories: Health & Fitness
Type: BOOK - Published: 2003-07-08 - Publisher: Shambhala Publications

"Here is a comprehensive survey of the full breadth and depth of the 5,000-year-old Yoga tradition, emphasizing its potent philosophy and spiritual vision. Geor